| Team | Points | Year | Against |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chicago St. Rita | 111 | 2021 | Yorkville Christian |
| Champaign Central | 109 | 2011 | East Peoria |
| Chicago Uplift | 106 | 2016 | Marmion Academy |
| Yorkville Christian | 103 | 2021 | Chicago St. Rita |
| Indianapolis T.C. Howe | 103 | 2017 | Illini Bluffs |
| Gary Lew Wallace | 99 | 2010 | Chicago Perspectives |
| Montgomery Carver | 94 | 2011 | East Peoria |
| Greensboro Smith | 93 | 2017 | Urbana |
| Wilkinson County | 93 | 2006 | Lake Howell |
| Yorkville Christian | 92 | 2021 | Washington |
| Sam Houston MSTC | 92 | 2017 | St. Louis Confluence |
| St. Louis Confluence | 91 | 2017 | Urbana |
| St. Louis Whitfield | 91 | 2009 | Varna Midland |
| Winston-Salem Christian | 90 | 2021 | Rabun Gap-Nacoochee |
| Indianapolis Manual | 90 | 2016 | Urbana |
| Spartanburg Day School | 89 | 2016 | Proviso East |
| Chicago Boys to Men | 89 | 2006 | Humble Christian Life Center |
| Hazelwood Central | 89 | 2009 | Limestone |
| Kinston | 89 | 2008 | Lake Forest Academy |
| O’Fallon | 89 | 2010 | Champaign Central |
| Springfield Lanphier | 88 | 2021 | Yorkville Christian |
| Pewaukee | 88 | 2021 | Pattonville |
| Washington | 88 | 2008 | Fayette County |
| Chicago De La Salle | 88 | 2008 | Richland |
| Proviso East | 88 | 2011 | Peoria Notre Dame |