| Notable NAIA and Division III Alumni |
List includes Central Illinois players and Elite small college players |
| +Nate Rakestraw, Biola |
Springdale Har-Ber |
| +Sean Johnson, Illinois Wesleyan |
Washington |
| +Travis Rosenkranz, Illinois Wesleyan |
Macon Meridian |
| +P.J. Shannon, Central Baptist |
Sprindale Har-Ber (Scored 1st two points in ToC History) |
| +Dexter Walker, Illinois Wesleyan |
Morton |
| +Tyler Ruschmeyer, North Central |
Pekin |
| +Jackson Scott, Millikin |
Washington |
| +Jake Willis, Monmouth |
East Peoria |
| +Greg Schrimpf, Wisconsin-Oshkosh |
Roncalli Catholic |
| +Chris Donnelly, Saint Ambrose |
Peoria Notre Dame |
| +Tanner Carlson, Knox College |
Annawan |
| +James Hollins, Lewis & Clark College |
Phoenix Saint Mary’s |
| +Drew Blumenshiine, Illinois Wesleyan |
Peoria Notre Dame |
| +Jamie King, Trinity Christian College |
Pekin |
| +Doug Lillibridge, Knox College |
Byron |
| +Ben Worner, Olivet Nazarene |
Washington |
| +Mark Lessen, Eureka College |
Delavan |
| +De Marius Sumrell, William Woods |
Limestone |
| +Brady Zimmer, Illinois Wesleyan |
Delavan |
| +Brett Meinecke, Edgewood College |
Sussex Hamilton |
| +Jake Rutan, Loras College |
Chillicothe IVC |
| +Kenny Rhymes, Texas Wesleyan |
Chicago Hales Franciscan |
| +Josh Fenoglia, Eureka College |
Varna Midland |
| +Josh Hack, Eureka College |
Washington |
| +Zac Van de Water, Indiana Wesleyan |
Whitko |
| +Mark Roth, Augustana |
Washington |
| +Alex Cline, Loras College |
East Peoria |
| +Aaron Abram, Oklahoma Baptist |
Gary Lew Wallace |
| +Ben Ryan, Augustana |
Washington |
| +T.J. Griffin, Millikin |
Mc Cluer |
| +Logan Irwin, Grace College |
Whitko |
| +Dalton Wagler, Holy Cross College |
Washington |
| +Sam Feehan, Eureka College |
Peoria Notre Dame |
| +Fred Greer, Robert Morris-Peoria |
Champaign Central |
| +Lane Mahurin, Indiana Wesleyan |
Rockville |
| +Xavier Newson, Goshen |
Peoria Richwoods |
| +Jacob Johnston, Augustana |
Erie |
| +Tucker Harlan, Elmhurst College |
Washington |
| +Brody Gronewold, Missouri Valley College |
Illini West |
| +Caleb Mortag, Wisconsin-Whitewater |
Brookfield Central |
| +Mason Schaub, Elmhurst College |
Chillicothe IVC |
| +Joel Heesch, Carroll University |
Mauston |
| +Kendall Davis, Mac Murray College |
Limestone |
| +Martavian Payne, Lindenwood-Belleville |
St. Louis Imagine Prep |
| +Nic Reynolds, Columbia College |
Peoria Notre Dame |
| +Hank Mathews, Columbia College |
Peoria Notre Dame/ Limestone |
| +Branden Jenkins, Texas Wesleyan |
Proviso East |
| +Chet Griffith, Eureka College |
Washington |
| +Beau Bommarito, Emory University |
St. Louis CBC |
| +Edvinas Rupkus, Skidmore College |
Westtown School |
| +Alex Wiegand, Eureka College |
Washington |
| +Tay Hardy, LSU-Shreveport |
Campti Lakeview |
| +Brenton Toussaint, John Brown University |
Campti Lakeview |
| +Germaine Roebuck, Calumet College of St. Joseph |
Champaign Central |
| +Ta Juan Johnson, Central Baptist College |
Proviso East |
| +Kurt Hall, Kentucky Christian |
North Chicago |
| +Josh Roberts, Roosevelt University |
Chicago Westinghouse |
| +Jo Jo Anderson, Our Lady of the Lake |
La Lumiere School |
| +Melvin Lee, Mount Mercy |
Milwaukee Riverside University |
| +Breck Biedscheid, Monmouth College |
Washington |
| +Toraze Dobbs, East-West University |
Chicago Uplift |
| +Raheem McKee-Strong, Mount Mercy |
DePue |
| +Patrick Torrey, St. Ambrose |
Pekin |
| +Gabe Cox, Culver Stockton College |
Winchester West Central |
| +Cole Howard, Culver Stockton College |
Winchester West Central |
| +Jake Wolf, Washington University-St. Louis |
Lake Forest Academy |
| +Everett Stubblefield, Central Methodist |
Proviso East |
| +Tyler Bass, Loras College |
Washington |
| +Kashie Natt, LSU-Alexandria |
Rayville |
| +Pee Wee Brown, Eureka College |
Peoria Manual |
| +Justice Marmara, University of the Ozarks |
Goodyear Millennium |
| +Dannie Smith, Indiana Northwest |
Chicago Orr |
| +Keegan Zimmerman, Dubuque |
Eureka |
| |
|
| CURRENT PLAYERS |
|
| Kawika Akina, New York University, sr. |
Pleasant Grove |
| Andrew Coker, Eureka College, sr. |
Washington |
| Emaryon Byrd, Eureka College, sr. |
Peoria Manual |
| Damuzah Moore, Eureka College, sr. |
Urbana |
| Donavan Short, St. Thomas, sr. |
Denmark |
| Tyler Burrows, Park, sr. |
Yorkville Christian |
| Zyquarius Cowart, Centenary, sr. |
Rayville |
| Riyaan Jiwani, New York University, sr. |
Pacifica Christian |
| Myles Murphy, Huntingdon College, sr. |
Mc Gill-Toolen Catholic |
| David Williams, Illinois Wesleyan, sr. |
Peoria Notre Dame |
| Omari Bolden, North Carolina Wesleyan, sr. |
Quality Education Academy |
| Austin Prater, Central Methodist, sr. |
Pattonville |
| Darius Duff, Blackburn College, sr. |
Lake Forest Academy |
| Ty Lampley, Harris-Stowe State College, sr. |
Belleville West |
| Emmett Loew, Loras College, sr. |
Pewaukee |
| |
|
| Micah Bruer, Eureka College, jr. |
Washington |
| DJ Henry, Cal State-Maritime, jr. |
Saint John Bosco |
| Aaron Brown, Concordia-Chicago, jr. |
Joliet West |
| Ian Cook, University of Puget Sound, jr. |
St. John Bosco |
| Mateo Duran, Drew University, jr. |
St. John Bosco |
| Maddux Dieckman, Augustana College, jr. |
Moline |
| Abram Fields, Judson, jr. |
Yorkville Christian |
| Landon Key, Lawrence, jr. |
Wisconsin Lutheran |
| Riley Rindfleisch, UW-Oshkosh, jr. |
Wisconsin Lutheran |
| Austin Robinson, Illinois College, jr. |
Springfield Lanphier |
| Demontrel Jones, Principia College, jr. |
St. Louis Cardinal Ritter |
| Cameron Noel, Florida Memorial, jr. |
College Park |
| Jared Bonds, Saint Mary of the Woods, jr. |
Carmel |
|
|
| Jaedin Reyna, Marian University, so. |
Chicago St. Rita |
| Braden Walters, Marian University, so. |
Linton-Stockton |
| Tyrese Mayo, Warner, so. |
Winter Haven |
| Logan Rindfleisch, UW-Oshkosh, so. |
Wisconsin Lutheran |
| Grayson Young, North Central-Minnesota, so. |
Wisconsin Lutheran |
| Troy McPherson, St. Lawrence, so. |
Rabun Gap-Nacoochee |
| Zayne Vernon, Red Deer Polytechnic College, so. |
Rabun Gap-Nacoochee |
| Nashawn Davis, Columbia College, so. |
St. Louis Cardinal Ritter |
| James Porter, Missouri Valley College, so. |
St. Louis Cardinal Ritter |
| Konrad Anderson, Luther College, so. |
Indian Trail Academy |
| Israel Bolton, Minnesota North College, so. |
Indian Trail Academy |
| Vinnie Adjahoungbeta, Elmhurst College, so. |
Moline |
| Deken Jones, Oklahoma Wesleyan, so. |
Dale |
| Deacon Perry, Willamette, so. |
Heritage Christian |
| Alex Maas, Illinois Wesleyan, so. |
Heyworth |
| Chancesaye Maxon, Greenville, so. |
El Paso-Gridley |
| Myan Whitfield, Loras College, so. |
Chicago Lincoln Park |
| Tevonta Jackson, Barclay College, so. |
Springfield Lanphier |
| Myles Baker, Wabash College, so. |
Lawrence North |
| |
|
| Wes Gudeman, Williams College, fr. |
Morton |
| Malachi Persinger, Hannibal-LaGrange, fr. |
Peoria Christian |
| Micah Meiss, Illinois Wesleyan, fr. |
El Paso-Gridley |
| Karson Osterman, UW-Superior, fr. |
Pewaukee |
| Trayden Chambers, Manhattan Christian College, fr. |
Dale |
| Chris Hurt, IU-South Bend, fr. |
Crispus Attucks |
| Eric Jackson, IU-Columbus, fr. |
Crispus Attucks |
| Lamar Jones, Marian University, fr. |
Crispus Attucks |
| Ronisone Thomas, William Penn, fr. |
Crispus Attucks |
| Owen Walther, Macalester College, fr. |
St. Louis John Burroughs |
| Bradley Stratton, Wabash College, fr. |
St. Laurence |
| Alex Cuoto, Huntington University, fr. |
Carmel |
| Amari Morgan, Georgia Gwinnett College, fr. |
Sugar Hill Lanier |
| Zach Marini, Buena Vista University, fr. |
Yorkville Christian |
| Chase Rhone, Missouri Baptist, fr. |
St. Louis St. Mary’s |
| Nisani Mendez, Arizona Christian, fr. |
Rabun Gap-Nacoochee |
| Brendan Beaumont, Carroll University, fr. |
Benet Academy |
| CJ Duncan, Loras College, fr. |
Washington |
